|
| Grinds
So Fine
Excerpted
from Coffee and Tea New Europe Exhibition and Symposiums Vienna,
Austria
|
|
|
|
|
| It
has long been standard practice in the industry to manufacture "normal"
grinds, such as coarse, filter fine and espresso, on roller style
grinding equipment. The challenge presented to us, in this case, was
to use this same type of technology to produce the finest of all grinds,
"Ultrafine", or Turkish, style coffee. When we approached
this challenge, there were several issues we had to understand, which
I would like to refer to as the "P" factors.
The first "P"
factor is Product, or, what exactly is the coffee product that we
are trying to manufacture: The second "P" factor is the
Problem, or what problems are being experienced using the present
grinding technologies? *("Ultrafine" refers to Turkish,
Grecian, Lebanese and similar grinds). The third "P" factor
refers to the new Process, or grinder design for manufacturing that
defines Product. And the fourth "P" would be what we might
call "P" ("P" Prime), which is the resulting
new ground coffee product
The first "P"
was understanding the product that we were trying to make. For purposes
of this discussion, we will define the Turkish, Grecian and Lebanese
type coffee as "Ultrafine". "Ultrafine" style
coffees were the earliest methods of brewing coffee, and one might
call them the original "instant" coffees, long before
freeze dried and agglomerated. The coffee drinking population of
"Ultrafine" type coffees is estimated at 700 million people
throughout the world, and since the earliest days "stones"
and "plates" have been used to grind this coffee into
a fine powder. To get an idea of how fine this might be, let's do
a little comparison.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| If
we were to take a single roasted coffee bean and reduce it into, say,
a French press or coarse grind, it would result in about 200 particles,
or individual pieces. If we take another coffee bean, and break it
into a Silex or drip grind, it would result in about 600 particles.
If we take another coffee bean, and break it into a "filter fine"
grind, it would result in the generation of up to 3,000 particles.
Finally, if we take a coffee bean and break it into an "Ultrafine",
or Turkish grind, it would result in the generation of about 45,000
particles of coffee. What has essentially occurred here is a controlled
"explosion" of the coffee bean into about 45,000 separate
particles.
Now, comes the
second "P" or the Problem. As one can imagine, to make
such a fine grind requires a great deal of energy. Imagine taking
a coffee bean and hitting it with a hammer. The first time you hit
it, it breaks into a coarse grind or, something on the order of
a French press or drip type grind. If we hit the hammer on the bean
several more times, it would progressively get finer and finer and,
eventually, become something on the order of a Turkish coffee grind.
In essence, the energy that is represented by the hammer and the
muscles in your arm is the same type of energy that is needed to
make a coffee grind progressively finer. Since one of the basic
laws of thermodynamics says that all energy goes eventually to heat,
the energy that is required to make this fine grind coffee eventually
results in a great deal of heat being transferred to the coffee.
With the typical plates and stones that are utilized now in the
manufacture of "Ultrafine" type coffees, the energy needed
to make the grind is transferred into the product.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| As
the coffee is ground progressively finer using plates and stones,
the heat generation increases steadily to a point of about 60-80 degr.
C after one hour and about 100 degr. C after two hours of operation.
This situation
causes several problems: The critically important flavor and aromatic
constituents of the coffee are volatile, or sensitive to heat, and
evaporate or "boil off" at these elevated temperatures.
There are several
temperature levels at which volatile, aromatics evaporate. Some
are as low as 40 degr. C, others at 60 degr. C, while others are
at 80 degr. C; however, virtually all evaporate by the time 100
degr. C is reached.
The second problem,
related to the first, is the inability to produce coffee on a continuous
basis. The typical Turkish grinder must be shut down when it reaches
100 degr. C and a cooling grinder temperature to be reduced close
to ambient. Obviously, this is a major interruption to production
and can reduce the capacity of a grinder by 75%.
The third problem,
related again to the above, is that involving the color of the coffee
itself. The best place to develop a coffee, and its color is in
the roaster. Grinders have never made very good roasters, and the
development of darker and darker coffee in these grinders is inevitable
considering the amount of heat that is generated in the grinding
process.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| The
fourth problem, a result of the use of burrs and stone, involves the
particles distribution, or grind. Because of the nature of grinding
plates and burrs, there is a widespread variation in the particle
size of the grind produced.
We can summarize
then that the problems are heat generation, which causes the loss
of flavor and aromatics in the coffee, the interruption of production,
the darkening of the coffee color inside the grinder, and the grind
particles size itself.
The third "P"
is the new Process, or the design of the new Model FT "Ultrafine"
coffee grinder. Pictured below is an overview of a typical type
of modern coffee roller style grinder. As can be seen, the coffee
enters the top section through the distribution feeder, and is progressively
ground finer and finer. Upon discharge from the grinding chamber,
it enters into a homogenizing or normalizing chamber where coffee
densification, chaff elimination and cooling occur.
|
To
address these challenges, the Model FT "Ultrafine" grinder
was developed. Because of the need to control this coffee explosion,
it was necessary to incorporate several features including the following:
|
 |
- The coffee
temperature had to be monitored and controlled throughout the
grinding sections to insure the optimal coffee conditions.
- Control of
the loading of each motor throughout the grinder had to be maintained.
|
- Automatic
control of the feed rate into the grinder to match the motor loading
had to be insured.
- Water cooling
on all rollers as well as the normalizer/homogenizer had to be
included as an integral part of the unit.
- The most
crucial element of the Model FT was that involving durability
and wear. Since the grind that was being achieved was "Ultrafine",
the tolerances obviously were going to be far more stringent than
ever required previously; additionly, due to the amount of energy
and work that was to be performed in the grinder, an accelerated
amount of wear could be expected.
To address this
problem, we relied on ultra-hard materials that have been developed
by the U.S. Space program (NASA). By utilizing these licensed, propriety
materials, we have been able to virtually eliminate wear from occurring
on the grinding sections. Not only does this remove the element
of maintenance and down time from the operation of the FT, but also
ensures the critical tolerances necessary to make this grind, are
maintained.
Now, for the
final "P" or P' ("P" Prime), we look at the
new "Ultrafine" product achieved on the Model FT "Ultrafine".
|
|
|
|
|
|
| First,
let's look at heat. Whereas, the old temperatures rose right through
the various volatile aromatic and flavor levels, the FT's temperature
levels are well below those evaporation temperatures. This means that
the first three problems, which were the loss of volatiles and aromatics,
the darkening of the coffee inside the grinder, and the necessity
to shut down the grinder to cool off, have all been eliminated. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Secondly,
let's look at the particle distribution of the "Ultrafine"
product or, the grind itself. The larger particles, those that are
to the right of the scale, represent the previously achieved oversized
particles which have a tendency to become an undesirable part of the
brewed coffee.
Summarizing,
the problems that have been inherent in the grinding of "Ultrafine"
coffee, such as Turkish, Grecian, Lebanese and others, are now eliminated
through the use of the MPE Model FT "Ultrafine" roller
style grinder. The results are a cool, uniform coffee grind produced
on a grinder that is capable of running 24 hours a day, 7 days per
week.
Written
by Glenn A.John, International Editor, Tea and Coffee Trade Journal
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|